The Law Reports (Queen's Bench Division)
[1986] QB 892
[EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE]
HURD
v.
JONES
(Case 44/84)
1985 March 7;
May 22;
1986 Jan. 15
May 22;
1986 Jan. 15
President U. Everling Presidents of Chambers K. Bahlmann and R. Joliet Judges G. Bosco, O. Due, Y. Galmut, C. N. Kakouris and T. F. O'Higgins Advocate General Sir Gordon Slynn
European Court of Justice
— Reference to
— Jurisdiction
— Statute and Protocol setting up European schools
— Agreement linked to, but not part of, Community law
— Whether court having jurisdiction to interpret
— Whether jurisdiction limited to scrutiny and scope
—
E.E.C. Treaty (Cmnd. 5179-II), art. 177
—
E.E.C. Act of Accession (Cmnd. 5179-I), art. 3(1)
European Economic Community
— European schools
— Adoption of Statute and Protocol
— Original member states adopting school governors' decision under Statute
— Whether United Kingdom in same position
—
E.E.C. Act of Accession (Cmnd. 5179-I), art. 3(1)(3)
European Economic Community
— Mutual co-operation and assistance
— Matters outside framework of Community law
— Payment of European supplement to teachers in European schools
— Taxation of English national's supplement payable in England
— Behaviour affecting Community finances
— Whether contravention of duty able to be relied on by individual in proceedings against member state
—
E.E.C. Treaty (Cmnd. 5179-II), art. 5
Discrimination, Race
— Nationality
— Taxation
— English national teaching in European school in England
— Taxation of European supplement
— Payments to other nationals not taxed
— Whether discrimination against own nationals
— Whether United Kingdom required to comply with school governors' decision relating to taxation
—
E.E.C. Treaty (Cmnd. 5179-II), art. 7