[HOUSE OF LORDS]
SIR CHARLES MORDAUNT, BART. APPELLANT; SIR THOMAS MONCREIFFE, BART. (AS LADY MORDAUNT'S GUARDIAN ad litem) RESPONDENT.
1874 May 15.
1874 June 22.
MR. JUSTICE BRETT, MR JUSTICE KEATING, and LORD CHIEF BARON KELLY LORD CHELMSFORD and LORD HATHERLEY.
Divorce against a WifeHer Insanity no Bar.

A petition for divorce against a wife was met by an allegation of her insanity and consequent inability to defend herself. The Court below appointed a guardian ad litem on her behalf. Upon a verdict of her insanity, proceedings were suspended; but with liberty to the husband to apply again to the Court in the event of her recovery. The husband appealed to the House of Lords, insisting that the wife's insanity ought not to bar, or impede, the investigation of the charge of adultery brought against her. The House adopted this view; and, reversing the order appealed against, sent the case back with directions to proceed.

Divorce on behalf of an insane Husband or Wife.

Per LORD CHELMSFORD:— The question whether proceedings for the dissolution of a marriage can be instituted on behalf of a lunatic husband or wife, it is unnecessary to determine, as it involves considerations very different from those which occur in the Mordaunt case.

Opinions of the Consulted Judges as to Divorce in Cases of Insanity.

Chief Baron Kelly, Mr. Justice Denman, and Mr. Baron Pollock concurred 375in holding that divorce may be asked and decreed on behalf of, or against, a lunatic, the Court appointing a guardian ad litem for protection; but Mr. Justice Keating and Mr. Justice Brett were of opinion that the insanity of either husband or wife is an absolute bar to divorce.

Adultery not a Crime.

Subscribe or Register to access the full Law Report. Registered users can access three Law Reports, three case information pages and perform three Case Genie searches per month. If you already have an ICLR account please log in. For other queries or to request a free trial please contact ICLR.

MoJ users should log in here.

We use cookies on this website, you can read our Privacy and Cookies Policy. To use website as intended please Accept Cookies