[HOUSE OF LORDS]
MR. AND MRS. SMITH CUNINGHAME et al. APPELLANTS; MRS. ANSTRUTHER et al. RESPONDENTS. et è contra.
1872 April 25.
THE LORD CHANCELLOR, LORD CHELMSFORD and LORD WESTBURY.
A Father's Power of Appointment under his Marriage Settlement.

Where a father was, by his marriage settlement, empowered to divide at discretion the funds in which the children had an expectant interest:—

Held, that he could not deal or negotiate with them in executing the power.

Per THE LORD CHANCELLOR:— A parent in, such a case purchasing the interests of the children, one of them being only eighteen years of age, is a transaction wholly inconsistent with that protection which the law of every civilised country affords to children; and would not be permitted without the fullest evidence of an intention authorizing it.

Held, reversing the decree below, that releases or discharges granted by the children to the father, in consideration of money payments made by him, formed no bar to their subsequent claims under the settlement, — such releases or discharges notwithstanding.

A Power may be executed without any Express Reference to it.

Per LORD CHELMSFORD:— The donee of a power may execute it without referring to it, and without taking the slightest notice of it, provided the intention to execute the power really appears.

Appointments pro tanto.

The power may be exercised from time to time by several appointments, to suit convenience and promote advantage, as exigencies arise, or as expediency may suggest.

Per LORD WESTBURY:— Some of the learned Judges of the Court below seem to have thought that the power required an execution uno flatu, once for all. If that were so, no appointment to a child, though settled in life, could take place until all the other children, objects of the power, had attained maturity.

Special Judgment.

Subscribe or Register to access the full Law Report. Registered users can access three Law Reports, three case information pages and perform three Case Genie searches per month. If you already have an ICLR account please log in. For other queries or to request a free trial please contact ICLR.

MoJ users should log in here.

We use cookies on this website, you can read our Privacy and Cookies Policy. To use website as intended please Accept Cookies